Advisers call on FCA to strengthen investor protections after Woodford IM failure

– Liquidity mismatches seen as main reason for failure of Woodford Equity Income

– Advisers sharpen focus on liquidity, while discounting fund manager reputation

– Open-ended property funds less likely to find favour in wake of Woodford 

Research into financial advisers’ attitudes to the collapse of Woodford Investment Management has revealed that advisers are paying more attention to the liquidity of investments, and less to fund manager reputation.

The research from the Association of Investment Companies (AIC) found that the most common lessons advisers have learned from Woodford are to give more consideration to liquidity when choosing investments (47% of respondents) and to be less trusting of a fund manager’s reputation (41%).

Three-quarters of advisers (75%) have changed their behaviour in some way as a result of Woodford. The most common behaviour changes are to check the level of exposure to unquoted companies in funds (37%), discount fund manager reputation in investment decisions (29%), and read fund factsheets (23%) and prospectuses (10%) in greater detail.

There is widespread agreement that there are insufficient controls on how funds operate where they hold illiquid assets, with 72% agreeing with this statement versus 10% who disagree. A total of 69% of respondents believe the FCA should impose stronger investor protections where illiquid assets are held in funds.

The research was conducted by Research in Finance on behalf of the AIC1.Richard Stone, Chief Executive of the Association of Investment Companies (AIC), said: “Our research shows that the suspension of Woodford Equity Income came as a surprise to most advisers, as it did to private investors. It has left them a lot more cautious about trusting a fund manager’s reputation or investing in a fund that has exposure to illiquid assets.

“Advisers clearly identify the Woodford fund’s exposure to unquoted companies as the number one reason behind its suspension and eventual failure. Whenever open-ended funds hold hard-to-sell assets, there will be a risk of such problems. The proposed Long-Term Asset Fund needs to be carefully designed to minimise such risks and, as an untested product, it should not be widely distributed until it has proved itself through an economic cycle.”

Further findings of the adviser research

Of the 106 advisers surveyed, a majority (58%) had at some point recommended to clients or invested on their behalf in Woodford Equity Income. Of these, 84% had clients who were impacted by the fund’s suspension in June 2019.

The collapse of Woodford Investment Management has left advisers less trusting of the investment industry. A majority (54%) said their trust in the industry had been weakened, and among those advisers who had clients impacted by the suspension, 62% trusted the industry less than before.

When asked about the main contributors to the collapse of Woodford Investment Management, the two most commonly cited reasons were the high proportion of unquoted companies (62% of respondents) followed by liquidity issues (55%).

Impact on attitude to open-ended property funds

Several open-ended funds with direct investments in property were suspended during the Covid-19 pandemic. The research reveals that advisers are now more cautious about investing in such vehicles.

Of all respondents, 69% had at some point recommended that clients invest in an open-ended property fund. However, only 12% currently recommend such funds, and only 11% say they would definitely do so in the future.

  1. This research was conducted by Research in Finance and commissioned by the AIC. It consisted of an online survey of 106 financial advisers, 52 of whom had clients who were impacted by the suspension of the Woodford Equity Income fund. This was followed up by ten in-depth interviews with financial advisers, selected from among the respondents to the online survey. Fieldwork was conducted between 16 June and 9 July 2021.
  2. The Woodford Equity Income fund operated under UCITS rules, which permit a maximum of 10% of a fund’s assets to be invested in less liquid assets such as unlisted securities. The FCA’s consultation paper CP21/12 on the proposed Long-Term Asset Fund (LTAF) specified that the regulator would expect more than 50% of an LTAF’s assets to be invested in unlisted securities and other long-term assets.

This Week’s Most Read

  • Baronsmead VCTs exit first sterling unicorn after Ideagen sale

    Gresham House’s Baronsmead VCTs have exited their stake in compliance software business Ideagen following its sale to private equity firm Hg Capital. The deal values

  • Fund Research Governance: is ‘fine’ good enough?

    Written by Laura Bampfylde, Director, Global Assets – Wealth, at Redington One of the most enlightening books I’ve read was written by husband-and-wife psychologists, Alan

  • ONS: Repossessions by county court bailiffs increase from 45 to 770 (1,611%)

    Following the latest Mortgage and landlord possession statistics published this morning, which reveal repossessions by county court bailiffs increased from 45 to 770 (1,611%) between

  • Creating a profitable HNW/LNW advice service in specialist markets

    By Simon Binney, Business Development Director, Wealth Wizards For financial planning firms targeting new clients, often the problem is not attracting clients to their business,

  • PIMCO: US CPI Preview

    By Tiffany Wilding, North American Economist, and Allison Boxer, Economist at PIMCO  This week focus turns to inflation, where recent commodity price weakness will become

  • #Podcast episode 7: JM Finn’s Sir John Royden on his superhuman swim for The Brain Tumour Charity

    This week’s podcast episode is something a bit different for IFA Talk…but certainly not an episode to be missed! Sue and Bex talk to Sir

  • FCA issues letter to alternative investment firms’ CEOs – experts comment

    The FCA has today issued a six page letter to CEOs of alternative investment firms about their supervisory strategy for such firms. David Newman, chief

  • Tackling Burnout in Financial Services

    Financial services professionals are increasingly suffering with stress which can often lead to burnout – a state of physical and emotional exhaustion. Latest research tells

  • Advisers concerned clients are risking HMRC fines over trusts

    Advisers are concerned about their clients risking HMRC fines, by failing to register trusts with the Trust Registration Service (TRS) by 1st September, according to

  • PIMCO’s Tiffany Wilding: The Era of Kinder, Gentler Central Banks Is Over

    By Tiffany Wilding, PIMCO’s North American Economist Last week, the Bank of England (BoE) was the first major central bank to admit that it is

Latest IFA Magazine Podcast Episodes

Keep updated on the most important financial events 

Make sure you are an informed

wealth professional..

Adblock Blocker

We have detected that you are using

adblocking plugin in your browser. 

IFA Magazine