- Women hold more ISAs than men.
- But they’re more likely to have a cash ISA, while men are more likely have a stocks and shares ISA.
- On average, men have £2,991 more in their ISAs than women. This gender ISA gap has doubled in a decade.
- But in 2021, women were increasingly likely to transfer a cash ISA to a stocks and shares ISA with HL.
Sarah Coles, senior personal finance analyst, Hargreaves Lansdown:
“Despite the super-human effort women are making to build their savings, the gender ISA gap has almost doubled in a decade to around £3,000. Women hold 52% of the UK’s ISAs, but they’re hampered by the fact so much of it is in cash.
Their reluctance to invest isn’t due to any natural difference between the sexes, much of it comes down to circumstances. On average, women earn less than men, and the more you earn, the more likely you are to have an investment ISA. It tends to reach a tipping point when our income reaches £30,000 – before then we’re more likely to have a cash ISA, and after that we’re more likely to favour stocks and shares.
Women also tend to have less secure incomes, so some may feel they cannot face the risk involved with investment. It does certainly mean facing the risk that investments will rise and fall in value over the short term. However, the way we tend to assess long-term risk is faulty. Women tend to over-estimate the risk that investments will lose money over the long term – overlooking the fact that on average they tend to rise. They also underestimate the risk their cash ISA will lose value after inflation. With the best easy access ISA without restrictions currently paying 0.66%, and inflation running at 5.5%, this is a racing certainty.
But not everything comes down to income. Despite the fact that the pay gap is much narrower among younger people, even among those aged 25 and under, men have more in their ISAs on average. In fact, there’s an imbalance between the sexes even among Junior ISA holdings, because 52% of children with an HL stocks and shares JISA are boys.
The fact that, on average, stocks and shares tend to outperform cash over the long term, means that women pay the price for sticking with cash. HMRC statistics show that men have an average ISA holding of £30,089 and women and average of £27,098 – which is a gender ISA gap of almost £3,000. That’s almost twice the gap ten years earlier.
The most recent HMRC statistics, for 2018/19 show that this divide is set to grow, because that year, men made up 57% of those paying into a stocks and shares ISA. This was up from 56% a year earlier and 55% in 2015/16.
However, more recently there are signs of more women considering investment. Our figures show that the number of women transferring a cash ISA to an HL stocks and shares ISA in 2021 was higher than a year earlier. They also made up a bigger percentage of those making the switch – at 42%, compared to 37% a year earlier.”
- 62% of people with an HL ISA are men.
- HMRC statistics show women are more likely to have a cash ISA: 4.4 million women only took out a cash ISA in 2018/19 – compared with 3.5 million men.
- And they’re less likely to invest in an ISA – in 2018/19 over a million men took out a stocks and shares ISA, while 785,000 women did.
- The gender ISA gap was £2,991 in 2018/19, up from £2,812 a year earlier, and almost doubling in a decade (from £1,550 in 2008/9).