Joint solution to FSCS and PII market flaws required says PFS

by | Apr 3, 2017

Share this article

Brown Shipley

As part of its submission to an FCA consultation, The Personal Finance Society (PFS) has called for a joint solution to what they regard are flaws in the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) and professional indemnity insurance (PII) market.

The PFS was responding to the FCA’s consultation, Reviewing the funding of the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS). It made the point that whilst it welcomed the FCA’s proposed review of the PII market later this year, it suggests that it should be more closely integrated with the current review into FSCS funding.

What worries the PFS is that proposals to reform the FSCS, due to be published by the regulator in the autumn 2017, will fail to take into account the outcomes of the later PII review.


PFS chief executive Keith Richards said: “Given the link between PII and the FSCS, and the dynamics of how insurance works in relation to the legacy liability of regulated advice, we need to find an integrated and sustainable solution that responds to the flaws in both markets.

“Any success the FSCS review achieves in terms of reducing the unpredictability of levies, and better aligning costs to the risk profiles of adviser and related firms, could be undermined if it results in less competition and higher premiums in the PII market.”

“Higher risk rated advice firms may even find it impossible to secure PII as a consequence, potentially forcing them into administration and thereby adding more liability into the FSCS.”


The PFS argument is that a single solution would work better. A central fund should be created with the financial capacity to protect both firms and consumers from advice firm failures.

Richards added: “It is pleasing that the FCA has acknowledged the need to more clearly link product risk to FSCS charges but it is disappointing that it has effectively ruled out the possibility of introducing a product levy.

“We have once in a generation opportunity to improve two markets in desperate need of reform and I’d urge the regulator to take an integrated approach and consider and investigate all options.”


“Ultimately, we must implement a solution that builds sustainability into the FSCS system, while promoting competition in the PII market.”

“Only then will cost pressures on firms be eased and smoothed, in turn making professional financial advice more affordable and accessible to consumers.”

Share this article

Related articles

Trending articles

IFA Talk logo

IFA Talk is our flagship podcast, designed to fit perfectly into your busy life, bringing the latest insight, analysis, news and interviews to you, wherever you are.

IFA Talk Podcast - listen to the latest episode