What does the G20 outcome mean for climate action and COP27? Think tank E3G highlights ‘unexpectedly strong message’

by | Nov 17, 2022

Share this article

  • Despite high geopolitical tensions driven by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, G20 leaders have sent a strong message to negotiators in Egypt to get a meaningful outcome from COP27. 
  • The G20 signalled the need for major financial system reforms to address global crises including climate change. They outlined the broad reforms needed and took useful steps, but clearly did not have consensus for rapid action across all reform areas. Unfinished business from this meeting will need to be taken forward urgently in 2023. 
  • Negotiators at COP27 now need to take their direction from this consensus to a deal on financing loss and damage, concrete plans for accelerating emissions reductions by agreeing global action to phase out all fossil fuels, and setting new political direction on the kinds of finance system transformation needed to deliver both climate and development goals. 

E3G, an independent climate change think tank, has shared its thinking on the latest news from Bali and Egypt as follows:

Geopolitics 

The G20 showed that climate change is still the top geopolitical issue, one of the first things to address in solving other crises.  

Nick Mabey, E3G Co-CEO said: 

 “Despite high geopolitical tensions driven by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the G20 leaders have sent an unexpectedly strong message on the need to accelerate collective action to tackle the energy, food, economic and climate crises. Leaders must now instruct their negotiators at COP27 to follow up these fine words with concrete outcomes” 

Climate Diplomacy 

Showing the fight for 1.5C does reflect global consensus, the G20 communique referred to the Glasgow Climate Pact’s calls to accelerate efforts to keep it within reach. The G20 called for countries to continue updating their NDCs. While the language is weaker than last year (an invitation to countries to enhance ambition rather than commitment to do so ‘where required’), it still reinforces the global direction of travel. The declaration calls for progress on loss and damage at COP – interestingly, in reference to finance, the call for enhancing innovative financing mechanisms could be a way to increase blocker countries’ comfort on new loss and damage funding arrangements. 

Alex Scott, Climate Diplomacy and Geopolitics expert at E3G said: 

 “This G20 outcome shows that the political sentiment from the COP27 world leaders’ summit – recognising the gaps to a safer climate pathway and calling for acceleration and finance system transformation to deliver it – reflects the global consensus and direction of travel. It shows political will to do more on climate and food security in particular, including raising the ambition and implementation of climate plans.

“But stating that will is not enough – the G20 as major emitters and economically advantaged need to step up to build on this outcome at COP27. This means a deal of financing loss and damage and clarity on how doubling adaptation finance will be achieved, concrete plans for accelerating emissions reductions by agreeing global action to phase out all fossil fuels and setting new political direction on the kinds of finance system transformation needed to deliver both climate and development goals.” 

Energy 

The Indonesians, despite some significant pressure, leant into the language on coal phase down. The communique holds the line on the Glasgow Climate Pact language, including a commitment to “Accelerating efforts towards the phasedown of unabated coal power” and medium-term phase down of inefficient fuel subsidies.  

Maria Pastukhova, Energy expert at E3G said:  

“The G20 outcome signals that clean energy is firmly at the heart of global energy security – and that efforts to water down language on coal and clean energy have proven outdated in the context of economic realities. Now, G20 countries need to mirror this ambition at COP and at home – by taking action to reduce energy waste as fast as possible and work towards clear pathways out of fossil fuel dependency to strengthen economic and geopolitical resilience of the bloc.” 

Camilla Fenning, Fossil Fuel transition expert at E3G said:  

“It’s good that the Indonesians, fresh from yesterday’s announcement of a $20 bn deal for their Just Energy Transition Partnership, ensured the Glasgow Climate Pact commitments on coal phase down were reiterated, calling for “accelerating efforts towards the phasedown of unabated coal power” and referencing phase out of inefficient fossil fuel subsidies. The onus is on COP27 now to recommit on coal phase down too.” 

Financial System Reform 

The G20 has added to calls for financial system reforms to address global crises including climate change, which have also been evident at COP27. It has agreed some useful actions, e.g. a timeline for MDB Capital Adequacy reforms and further steps on debt relief. A lack of consensus on key reform issues, such as greening international financial regulation, is evident and makes the final text overly cautious in some areas. 

Kate Levick, Associate Director for Sustainable Finance at E3G said: 

“We welcome G20’s statements on financial system architecture, in particular around MDB reforms and sovereign debt. Regulatory reforms agreed under the G20 SF Roadmap are also important for financial system reform that will support a sustainable climate transition for all countries, and it is concerning to see so much emphasis on these being ‘voluntary’ and ‘flexible’.” 

Share this article

Related articles

The OnePlanetCapital view on COP27

The OnePlanetCapital view on COP27

From a headline point of view the right things are being said at Cop 27. Biden has made big headline statements on reduction of methane; the US will enforce disclosure of climate impact on imports; the US and China will restart climate talks. The UK, after dithering...

SI Dilemmas: Keeping on course for net zero by 2050

SI Dilemmas: Keeping on course for net zero by 2050

The COP27 climate summit delivered a few wins but was disappointing overall. How do we keep on course for net zero in the absence of global cooperation? In our view, the net-zero transition will continue to gain traction, because paradoxically it appears that the lack...

Brooks Macdonald: COP27 conference was underwhelming

Brooks Macdonald: COP27 conference was underwhelming

Written by Ben Palmer, Head of Responsible Investment at Brooks Macdonald It’s fair to say that COP27 started with lower expectations than COP26, given the unfavourable macro backdrop of heightened geopolitical tensions, a global energy crisis and an economic downturn...

Trending articles