X

About

Advertise

Contact

Jobs

Tools for Advisers

Linkedin
Twitter
Facebook-f
  • News
    • In the Press
    • Politics and Finance
    • General
  • Featured
    • Podcasts & Films
    • Interviews
    • Events
    • Finance on Social Media
    • Jobs
    • MPS Report
  • GBI
    • Tax Efficient Investments
    • Open Investment Opportunities
    • People Behind the Product
    • GBI Magazine Issues
    • About GBI
  • Business
    • Regulation and Compliance
  • Magazines
  • The M&G Adviser Hub
Menu
  • News
    • In the Press
    • Politics and Finance
    • General
  • Featured
    • Podcasts & Films
    • Interviews
    • Events
    • Finance on Social Media
    • Jobs
    • MPS Report
  • GBI
    • Tax Efficient Investments
    • Open Investment Opportunities
    • People Behind the Product
    • GBI Magazine Issues
    • About GBI
  • Business
    • Regulation and Compliance
  • Magazines
  • The M&G Adviser Hub
Search
Close

About

Advertise

Contact

Jobs

Tools for Advisers

Untitled-1
Linkedin
Twitter
Facebook-f
  • News
    • In the Press
    • Politics and Finance
    • General
  • Featured
    • Podcasts & Films
    • Interviews
    • Events
    • Finance on Social Media
    • Jobs
    • MPS Report
  • GBI
    • Tax Efficient Investments
    • Open Investment Opportunities
    • People Behind the Product
    • GBI Magazine Issues
    • About GBI
  • Business
    • Regulation and Compliance
  • Magazines
  • The M&G Adviser Hub
Menu
  • News
    • In the Press
    • Politics and Finance
    • General
  • Featured
    • Podcasts & Films
    • Interviews
    • Events
    • Finance on Social Media
    • Jobs
    • MPS Report
  • GBI
    • Tax Efficient Investments
    • Open Investment Opportunities
    • People Behind the Product
    • GBI Magazine Issues
    • About GBI
  • Business
    • Regulation and Compliance
  • Magazines
  • The M&G Adviser Hub
Untitled-1
Linkedin
Twitter
Facebook-f

Analysis: it is time to accurately measure ESG performance

Insight and analysis into the challenge of standardised ESG reporting from Alberto Lopez Valenzuela, Founder and CEO of alva, 

by Sue Whitbread
November 27, 2020
in News
magnifying glass paper and pen look into data
Share this story

By Alberto Lopez Valenzuela, Founder and CEO of alva, the Stakeholder Intelligence company, and author of The Connecting Leader

There have lately been numerous voices calling for a single global reporting framework for environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues.

Blackrock has stated that enhanced, standardised sustainability reporting “is critical” to investors’ ability to account for material ESG factors, often known as intangibles. Vitaly Nesis, Chief Executive of London-listed gold producer Polymetal, subsequently pointed out that the current methods of scoring are often inconsistent, inaccurate and an exercise to “tick the boxes”.

In making this statement, he brought attention to the concern around performance measurement, something which grows among the investment community as ESG criteria increase in value.

Globally, the percentage of retail and institutional investors that apply ESG principles to a quarter or more of their portfolios leapt from 48% in 2017 to 75% in 2019. In 2018, sustainable investing assets totalled £10.9trn in Europe and £9.3trn in the United States. By 2025 ESG assets in the US are expected to hit £27.1trn.

The need for accurate metrics

With so much value being placed on sustainable investing, investors are seeking more accurate ways to measure ESG performance, and identify ESG risks to inform the investment process. This will help them to better identify companies likely to see good financial performance in the long-term due to their ESG-focused business models.

Finding a way for investors to accurately identify the best performers when constructing their investment strategy is important: a report by BofA Merrill Lynch revealed that a portfolio based on buying stocks in companies ranking well against various ESG metrics would have beaten the broader market by 3% every year for the last five.

The voluntary GRI Sustainability Reporting Standards represents one method of measurement, which was established in 2016 by the Global Reporting Initiative to support best practice in impact disclosure. Covering topics from tax to emissions, anticorruption, biodiversity and occupational health and safety, this aims to offer a flexible framework for creating integrated ESG reports.

More recently, in September 2020, the World Economic Forum (WEF) released a set of ‘stakeholder capitalism metrics’, designed to assist in the benchmarking of sustainable business performance. These metrics are centred on four pillars, encompassing a number of ESG factors: People, relating to diversity reporting, wage gaps, and health and safety; Planet, relating to greenhouse gas emissions, land protection, and water use; Prosperity, relating to employment and wealth generation, taxes paid, and research and development expenses; and finally Principles of governance, such as purpose, strategy, and accountability informing risk and ethical behaviour.

The WEF is encouraging businesses to include a full set of metrics in their corporate and financial reporting. But I agree with Vitaly Nesis that self-disclosure – something which continues to be encouraged by the WEF – is a recipe for inconsistency, subjectivity, and opacity.

How can we solve the problem?

There are many areas of ESG activity that aren’t represented in easily reportable figures, don’t have generally accepted measurement criteria, or which defy clear definition. They don’t generate a pithy soundbite to include in annual reports, or statistics to present to the board. There is no neat package for complete ESG reporting.

Furthermore, the importance and prevalence of different areas of ESG activity varies from sector to sector and indeed from company to company. There is a huge risk that many companies will be oversimplifying their ESG reporting to just what can easily and consistently be measured, rather than what actually matters.

So how can we close the current reporting gap? I argue that there is a need for other tracking measures, not only to help investors but also so that companies themselves can gain a realistic understanding of their own position on ESG. These measures need to take into account the reality of ever-shifting perspectives through real-time analysis of publicly available print, online, broadcast, and social media content. Reporting needs to incorporate:

  1. Comprehensive data, beyond company disclosures, be they voluntary or mandatory
  2. Sector-specific ESG topics, classifying and weighting using industry best practice (e.g. Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) standard taxonomy)
  3. Sector benchmarking, to understand how a company’s ESG profile compares to other businesses operating in the same environment
  4. Stakeholder specific factors, to reflect the competing demands and perspectives on ESG topics that different stakeholders have
  5. Rigorous scoring, both for overall ESG performance and also the materiality of the ESG issues faced, be they risks or opportunities
  6. Traceable data, to enable scores and movements to be linked back to their underlying drivers
  7. Real-time reporting, to reflect the speed with which ESG issues are evolving

This would of course mean a huge volume of data to process, but machine learning and natural language processing (NLP) technology can help to create an ESG scoring system to offer a reliable, objective overview of risk and potential.

Such scoring could be delivered to shareholders to help them to make truly informed investment decisions – while also allowing companies to make better strategic decisions.

About Alberto Lopez Valenzuela

alva,’s Founder and CEO, Alberto Lopez Valenzuela has spent more than 25 years working in business information and analysis. Alberto is a recognised business thought leader who has been a Visiting Professor at Cass School of Business and is a regular speaker on a variety of issues, including the business impact of reputation, data analytics techniques and personal experiences as an entrepreneur.  Alberto’s book, The Connecting Leader, examines how corporate leaders connect businesses with society, especially in this age of hyper-transparency, interconnectivity and media anarchy.

 

 

Previous Post

Savings ratio second peak forecast as BoE figures show wealthy Brits have saved more through pandemic

Previous Post

Newable Ventures and Bristol Private Equity Club secure £10m commitment from British Business Investments

Previous Post

Revolut looks to expand in Germany

Next Post

Oxford Technology’s monthly EIS pitch event over Zoom

Next Post

A Black Friday for Arcadia as it edges towards collapse

Next Post

RPI reform: result as expected – market reaction not

Related Posts

Pembroke VCT sees 2.3x exit in 12 months
News

Pembroke VCT sees 2.3x exit in 12 months

January 15, 2021
£122 billion inflation blow for pensioners and investors
News

Good news for investors as M&G Investments reduces annual charge across large proportion of OEIC funds

January 15, 2021
MP’s put FCA under the microscope
Finance on Social Media

London Capital & Finance judicial review

January 15, 2021
ThinCats
News

Supreme Court judgement in FCA’s business interruption insurance test case

January 15, 2021
UK business prepares to reopen
News

FTSE 100 lower as unsettling economic news overshadows stimulus optimism

January 15, 2021
‘A very difficult March for all participants in the housing market,’ says Ray Boulger
Feature

New UK levy on assets above £500,000 – what do private clients need to know?

January 14, 2021
Next Post
Oxford Technology’s monthly EIS pitch event over Zoom

Oxford Technology's monthly EIS pitch event over Zoom

A Black Friday for Arcadia as it edges towards collapse

A Black Friday for Arcadia as it edges towards collapse

UK inflation

RPI reform: result as expected – market reaction not

Podcasts & Films

  • Put an atomic clock in your car, phone and on your wrist
    January 13, 2021
  • The Nexus Scale-Up Fund walk through
    December 21, 2020
  • Net4 x ARIE Capital webinar, hosted by CoInvestor
    December 18, 2020
  • How does Nexus Communicate with clients?
    December 18, 2020
  • Nexus Investments – Reasons for Advisers to be positive in 2021
    December 17, 2020
  • The Nexus Story
    December 16, 2020

Today’s Most Read

  • Wirecard scandal: EY defends itself in the Bundestag
    January 14, 2021

    @peter_IFAMAG reads Twitter so you don’t have to. The Wirecard Investigation Team meets again at the Bundestag today. Prompted by investor action following the Wirecard

  • Brexit agreement leaves UK financial services operating under no deal scenarios
    January 11, 2021

    Tej Patel, Partner and Regulatory Practice Lead at Capco, comments on the continued uncertainty facing UK-based financial services firms post-Brexit. Given that financial services were

  • OnePlanetCapital launch new EIS fund
    January 11, 2021

    OnePlanetCapital, a new sustainably driven investment house, has today launched a specialist sustainability EIS Fund to invest in businesses tackling climate change. The new OnePlanetCapital

  • Former Man Group and Octopus Real Estate executives launch Silbury Finance
    January 14, 2021

    Two experienced property finance executives, backed by funds managed by Oaktree Capital Management, L.P. (“Oaktree”), have launched Silbury Finance (“Silbury”), a platform providing bespoke senior

  • Supreme Court judgement in FCA’s business interruption insurance test case
    January 15, 2021

    The Supreme Court delivers judgement in favour of policyholders in the FCA’s business interruption insurance test case The Supreme Court has substantially allowed the FCA’s appeal on

  • London Capital & Finance judicial review
    January 15, 2021

    @peter_IFAMAG reads Twitter so you don’t have to. The London Capital and Finance vehicle lost 11,625 investors £237m in January 2019. Today brings news that

  • New UK levy on assets above £500,000 – what do private clients need to know?
    January 14, 2021

    By Paul Fairbairn, partner at Cripps Pemberton Greenish On 9 December the self-styled and in no way government-affiliated Wealth Tax Commission published their findings. This

  • Unpicking the jargon of responsible investing
    January 12, 2021

    George Robinson, Business Development Manager for VALA Capital, wrote the following article to help explain the difference between ESG and Sustainable investing.   Investors are increasingly

  • The ten secrets to mastering a last-minute tax return
    January 11, 2021

    Your self-assessment tax return deadline is due by midnight on 31 January. Last year, 11.1 million people filed a return on time, more than 70,000

  • Canaccord unveils new ESG portfolios on Embark Platform
    January 12, 2021

    Canaccord Genuity Wealth today launches an Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) portfolio range available on Embark Platform. Financial advisers using the Embark Platform will now be

More Articles

Blackfinch Ventures: In the spotlight
Interviews

Blackfinch Ventures: In the spotlight

January 7, 2021
Making a positive difference at the cutting edge
Interviews

Making a positive difference at the cutting edge

January 7, 2021
Meet the manager of the M&G Global Listed Infrastructure Fund
Interviews

Meet the manager of the M&G Global Listed Infrastructure Fund

December 15, 2020
Par Equity is the bright EIS star of the North 
Interviews

Par Equity is the bright EIS star of the North 

November 23, 2020
What’s next for Mercia?
Interviews

What’s next for Mercia?

November 2, 2020
M&G Positive Impact Fund: Q&A with Ben Constable-Maxwell
Interviews

M&G Positive Impact Fund: Q&A with Ben Constable-Maxwell

October 21, 2020
People Behind the Product: Pippa Gawley, Zero Carbon Capital
GBI

People Behind the Product: Pippa Gawley, Zero Carbon Capital

October 7, 2020
People Behind the Product: Matthew Steiner, Stellar Asset Management
GBI

People Behind the Product: Matthew Steiner, Stellar Asset Management

October 6, 2020
People Behind the Product: Ewan Lloyd-Baker, Seismic Venture Partners
GBI

People Behind the Product: Ewan Lloyd-Baker, Seismic Venture Partners

October 5, 2020

About Us

​IFA Magazine – for today’s discerning financial and investment professional.

Published ten times a year, IFA Magazine has been winning a keen and enthusiastic following among Britain’s premier financial advisers, planners and paraplanners.

Newsletter

    Follow Us

    Linkedin
    Twitter
    Facebook-f

    © 2021 All rights reserved​ to IFA Magazine | Website by: Nivo Digital | Terms and Conditions

    Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!

    Adblock Blocker

    We have detected that you are using

    adblocking plugin in your browser. 

    Keep updated on the most important financial events 

    Make sure you are an informed

    wealth professional..

    IFA Magazine
    • News
      • In the Press
      • Politics and Finance
      • General
    • Featured
      • Podcasts & Films
      • Interviews
      • Events
      • Finance on Social Media
      • Jobs
      • MPS Report
    • GBI
      • Tax Efficient Investments
      • Open Investment Opportunities
      • People Behind the Product
      • GBI Magazine Issues
      • About GBI
    • Business
      • Regulation and Compliance
    • Magazines
    • The M&G Adviser Hub