X

About

Advertise

Contact

Linkedin
Twitter
Facebook-f
  • News
    • In the Press
    • Politics and Finance
  • Featured
    • Podcasts & Films
    • Interviews
    • Events
    • Finance on Social Media
    • Jobs
    • MPS Report
  • GBI
    • Tax Efficient Investments
    • Open Investment Opportunities
    • People Behind the Product
    • GBI Magazine Issues
    • About GBI
  • Business
    • Regulation and Compliance
  • Magazines
  • The M&G Adviser Hub
Menu
  • News
    • In the Press
    • Politics and Finance
  • Featured
    • Podcasts & Films
    • Interviews
    • Events
    • Finance on Social Media
    • Jobs
    • MPS Report
  • GBI
    • Tax Efficient Investments
    • Open Investment Opportunities
    • People Behind the Product
    • GBI Magazine Issues
    • About GBI
  • Business
    • Regulation and Compliance
  • Magazines
  • The M&G Adviser Hub
Search
Close

About

Advertise

Contact

Jobs

Tools for Advisers

Untitled-1
Linkedin
Twitter
Facebook-f
  • News
    • In the Press
    • Politics and Finance
  • Featured
    • Podcasts & Films
    • Interviews
    • Events
    • Finance on Social Media
    • Jobs
    • MPS Report
  • GBI
    • Tax Efficient Investments
    • Open Investment Opportunities
    • People Behind the Product
    • GBI Magazine Issues
    • About GBI
  • Business
    • Regulation and Compliance
  • Magazines
  • The M&G Adviser Hub
Menu
  • News
    • In the Press
    • Politics and Finance
  • Featured
    • Podcasts & Films
    • Interviews
    • Events
    • Finance on Social Media
    • Jobs
    • MPS Report
  • GBI
    • Tax Efficient Investments
    • Open Investment Opportunities
    • People Behind the Product
    • GBI Magazine Issues
    • About GBI
  • Business
    • Regulation and Compliance
  • Magazines
  • The M&G Adviser Hub
Untitled-1
Linkedin
Twitter
Facebook-f

Déjà vu: Alasdair McKinnon likens current tech market to the DotCom bubble

by Peter Wilson
October 15, 2020
in Feature, News
Share this story
Déjà vu: Alasdair McKinnon likens current tech market to the DotCom bubble
Share this story

Alasdair McKinnon is the Lead Fund Manager of The Scottish Investment Trust and spoke to IFA Magazine about why big tech stocks remind him of his experience during the DotCom Bubble.

The Scottish is an independently managed investment trust company which was formed in 1887 to provide investors with an efficient way to invest in companies around the world. The Scottish takes a contrarian approach to global stock markets, which they view as irrational and ultimately inefficient and as high-conviction investors, they focus on stocks that are out of favour with mainstream investors, as they believe that these offer the greatest potential for longterm gains. The Scottish has an unbroken run of 36 years of regular dividend growth, and it won the Shares Awards 2019 ‘Best Investment Trust’.

Pressed on where his own contrarian approach came from McKinnon explained that although based on various strands, its formative stage came during the DotCom Bubble. Exploring this further he explained that one of the biggest factors in the DotCom Bubble was the relatively easy money conditions following a demise in long term capital management. Although starting off as a sceptic McKinnon cites the purchase of Arms Holdings and Orange as a key decision. ‘I thought everyone is soon going to have a mobile phone, and if everyone owns a mobile phone, then I’ll invest in the chip’. This was in 1998, and as the DotCom boom happened McKinnon’s confidence grew. ‘Suddenly in the company I was this internet guru. After a while I got sucked into it.’

In an interesting analogy, McKinnon likened it to young sports stars adding ‘If you keep being successful you inevitably get more and more out of touch with reality.’ Speaking of his own experience and what he has seen in the investment industry, he added that ‘people start off level headed, they get a great idea and then any scepticism disappears, then the money floods in and then get a bust’

This brought us to the area of the stock market that has been thriving during the pandemic, Tech. McKinnon noted that ’a lot of tech stocks have clearly been beneficiaries of the COVID crisis. McKinnon highlighted that we’ve needed to buy hardware, and software on top of that, we’ve needed to pay for subscription for ways of communicating. It might be argued that the government and society as a whole picked its winners, with local smaller scale shops having to close and yet Amazon continuing to deliver. In terms of successes, alongside the Amazons’, McKinnon suggests whats done well are so-called “working from home stocks”. McKinnon said, The things exposed to the real world are still bombed out, especially in the UK market.’Before our interview McKinnon was talking about his invigorated passion for golf, and in his view a lot of people have changed their habits throughout lockdown.

Considering his experience during the Dot Com Bubble, I asked McKinnon what he thought of the tremendous tech stock rally in a historical context. We talked about a recent research that highlighted 6% of S&P 500 stocks are trading on a ratio of ten times value of earnings. ‘To get a pay back on a company on ten times sales, it’s not just a ten year payback – its a 50 year payback.’ McKinnon continued, ‘When you look at the darlings of twenty years ago, and where they are today – I know some people disagree with this – but they usually start off well and then decline. When you buy a generic group on a huge multiple of sales, yes they’ll be individual winners, but as a group you’re not in a good pool.’ Quick to add, ‘Does that mean they’re going to fall – not necessarily.’ However McKinnon talked of a phenomena present across industries, ‘as a company is on top it is likely already oscillating and the institution will not continue to flourish.’

McKinnon ended with an anecdote from his early career in the DotCom bubble, ‘I remember going into the office and parroting what I’d just heard on CNBC. I said I liked this stock, because even though its on 100 times earnings I know we can depend on these earnings… and the guy looked at me. I knew I was talking rubbish, and he knew I was talking rubbish but he didn’t want to say.’ McKinnon ended our conversation with one takeaway and a parallel to what happened during the DotCom Bubble, and something he sees emerging once again and that’s the situation where ‘Clever people are telling each-other things they don’t really believe in because that’s what they think people want to hear, that’s the climate we find ourselves in once more.’

Previous Post

Blackfinch unveils exciting new branding in ESG space

Previous Post

Don’t miss this tax planning event from Octopus

Previous Post

Invest in the sustainability leaders of tomorrow

Next Post

London Chamber of Commerce and Industry responds to London lockdown

Next Post

New app to provide information on global bond portfolios and selected collective investments

Next Post

Book your place on ESG and Evidence-Based Investing workshop

Related Posts

‘A very difficult March for all participants in the housing market,’ says Ray Boulger
News

The real and ongoing ramifications of the global pandemic

January 28, 2021
pension
News

Intra-day pensions transfers increase in 2020

January 28, 2021
Save the dates and register now
Events

Save the dates and register now

January 27, 2021
Gamestonk: Memes and market movement
Finance on Social Media

Gamestonk: Memes and market movement

January 27, 2021
IFA Magazine News red
News

PIMFA: little regulators can do to stop fraud without action from Government 

January 27, 2021
EQ Investors announces appointment of Victoria Hasler as Head of Fund Research
News

EQ Investors announces appointment of Victoria Hasler as Head of Fund Research

January 27, 2021
Next Post
London Chamber of Commerce and Industry responds to London lockdown

London Chamber of Commerce and Industry responds to London lockdown

New app to provide information on global bond portfolios and selected collective investments

New app to provide information on global bond portfolios and selected collective investments

Book your place on ESG and Evidence-Based Investing workshop

Book your place on ESG and Evidence-Based Investing workshop

Podcasts & Films

  • HAATCH Celebrating Entrepreneurs – Episode 2
    January 26, 2021
  • Put an atomic clock in your car, phone and on your wrist
    January 13, 2021
  • The Nexus Scale-Up Fund walk through
    December 21, 2020
  • Net4 x ARIE Capital webinar, hosted by CoInvestor
    December 18, 2020
  • How does Nexus Communicate with clients?
    December 18, 2020
  • Nexus Investments – Reasons for Advisers to be positive in 2021
    December 17, 2020

Today’s Most Read

  • Columbia Threadneedle appoints Michaela Collet Jackson as head of distribution
    January 21, 2021

    Columbia Threadneedle Investments, a leading global asset management group, announces the appointment of Michaela Collet Jackson as Head of Distribution EMEA. In this role, Michaela

  • EIS – looking to the future
    January 21, 2021

    EIS has been part of an adviser’s tax efficient tool kit for the last 26 years and now, more than £2 billion is invested annually

  • Square Mile’s 3D investing: new ratings and certifications in Q4  
    January 22, 2021

    Six funds awarded AAA 3D Impact ratings  Four funds awarded AA 3D Impact ratings  Three 3D Fund Certifications  3D Investing, Square Mile’s subsidiary dedicated to

  • Baillie Gifford Multi Asset Income Fund selected by Hargreaves Lansdown as investment pathways solution
    January 27, 2021

    The £82m Baillie Gifford Multi Asset Income Fund has been chosen by Hargreaves Lansdown as an ‘investment pathways’ solution for investors seeking non-advised drawdown. Investment

  • Gamestonk: Memes and market movement
    January 27, 2021

    @peter_IFAMAG reads Twitter so you don’t have to. There is one dominant finance story on Twitter today, and it surrounds the meteoric rise of Gamestop

  • Portfolio of BB Biotech AG as of December 31, 2020
    January 22, 2021

    Vaccines leading the way out of the pandemic – increased dividend of CHF 3.60 proposed BB Biotech performed well in 2020 in a volatile market

  • Retail investors pump the US stock market
    January 26, 2021

    @peter_IFAMAG reads Twitter so you don’t have to. Retail investors using internet site Reddit helped pump the price of Game Stop shares last night, leading

  • Ethical and sustainable funds among best performers in 2021 FE fundinfo Crown Ratings
    January 25, 2021

    In a year where ESG investing has hit the mainstream, ethical and sustainable funds have been among the best performers in the latest rebalance of

  • Are we in a bubble?
    January 27, 2021

    William Ryder , Equity Analyst at Hargreaves Lansdown examines market valuations “Veteran investor Jeremy Grantham at GMO recently published a widely circulated research article arguing that the

  • IPO and SPAC mania: what could possibly go wrong?
    January 25, 2021

    As investors throw money at IPOs and SPACs, Steve Russell, co-manager of the Ruffer Total Return Fund, says the promise of untold future profits should

More Articles

Blackfinch Ventures: In the spotlight
Interviews

Blackfinch Ventures: In the spotlight

January 7, 2021
Making a positive difference at the cutting edge
Interviews

Making a positive difference at the cutting edge

January 7, 2021
Meet the manager of the M&G Global Listed Infrastructure Fund
Interviews

Meet the manager of the M&G Global Listed Infrastructure Fund

December 15, 2020
Par Equity is the bright EIS star of the North 
Interviews

Par Equity is the bright EIS star of the North 

November 23, 2020
What’s next for Mercia?
Interviews

What’s next for Mercia?

November 2, 2020
M&G Positive Impact Fund: Q&A with Ben Constable-Maxwell
Interviews

M&G Positive Impact Fund: Q&A with Ben Constable-Maxwell

October 21, 2020
People Behind the Product: Pippa Gawley, Zero Carbon Capital
GBI

People Behind the Product: Pippa Gawley, Zero Carbon Capital

October 7, 2020
People Behind the Product: Matthew Steiner, Stellar Asset Management
GBI

People Behind the Product: Matthew Steiner, Stellar Asset Management

October 6, 2020
People Behind the Product: Ewan Lloyd-Baker, Seismic Venture Partners
GBI

People Behind the Product: Ewan Lloyd-Baker, Seismic Venture Partners

October 5, 2020

About Us

​IFA Magazine – for today’s discerning financial and investment professional.

Published ten times a year, IFA Magazine has been winning a keen and enthusiastic following among Britain’s premier financial advisers, planners and paraplanners.

Newsletter

    Follow Us

    Linkedin
    Twitter
    Facebook-f

    © 2021 All rights reserved​ to IFA Magazine | Website by: Nivo Digital | Terms and Conditions

    Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!

    Adblock Blocker

    We have detected that you are using

    adblocking plugin in your browser. 

    Keep updated on the most important financial events 

    Make sure you are an informed

    wealth professional..

    IFA Magazine
    • News
      • In the Press
      • Politics and Finance
    • Featured
      • Podcasts & Films
      • Interviews
      • Events
      • Finance on Social Media
      • Jobs
      • MPS Report
    • GBI
      • Tax Efficient Investments
      • Open Investment Opportunities
      • People Behind the Product
      • GBI Magazine Issues
      • About GBI
    • Business
      • Regulation and Compliance
    • Magazines
    • The M&G Adviser Hub